about-palestine
Do Arabs care about Palestine?
By Teymoor Nabili in
* Middle East
on August 2nd, 2010
.
To conclude that Arabs do not care about the Palestine issue on the
basis of a recent newspaper survey is wrong.
In The New York Times, Professor Efraim Karsh of King's College
London, draws our attention to a poll that suggests 71 per cent of
Arabs don't care about the Palestine issue.
At face value the statistic is pretty sobering, as are the conclusions
he draws from it.
Because of this "staggering" number, the Professor says, there is
absolutely no basis to the belief that the Palestine problem is
fuelling " regional anger and despair, [that gives] a larger rationale
to terrorist groups like al-Qaeda and to the insurgency in Iraq".
Then, citing a list of carefully chosen historical events, he glides
into the further conclusion that an even bigger problem for
Palestinians is active persecution by Arab governments. (Not even a
passing mention for any other Governments that may be party to this
particular issue.)
And the logical end product of this reasoning is that Palestinian
people might as well give up any hopes of being heard:
"The sooner the Palestinians recognise that their cause is theirs
alone, the sooner they are likely to make peace with the existence of
the State of Israel and to understand the need for a negotiated
settlement."
Many people will, of course, buy into this simplistic narrative, but
two basic problems stand out.
First - public ignorance and lack of concern about a chronic and
intractable geopolitical issue is far from "staggering" , it's the
norm in almost all countries, even the best educated.
It therefore seems rather foolish to base an entire political
philosophy on this one selective statistic.
But more importantly, the Professor appears to have entirely mis-
interpreted the very statistic upon which he bases his argument.
If 71 per cent of Arabs don't care about the Palestinian problem,
then, logically, 29 per cent do.
As a rough benchmark of the size of the Arab world, let's take
Wikipedia's word:
Twenty-five countries and territories with a combined population of
358 million people straddling North Africa and Western Asia.
--
-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=--=-=-=-=-=-=-=--=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=--=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
Serulah kepada jalan Tuhanmu dengan hikmah dan pelajaran yang baik
dan bantahlah mereka dengan cara yang lebih baik. -Qs. 16 an-Nahl :125
Berilah mereka pelajaran, dan katakanlah kepada mereka perkataan yang berbekas pada jiwa mereka. -Qs. 4 an-Nisa' : 63
Gabung : Milis_Iqra-subscribe@googlegroups.com
Keluar : Milis_Iqra-unsubscribe@googlegroups.com
Situs 1 : http://groups.google.com/group/Milis_Iqra
Mod : moderator.milis.iqra@gmail.com
-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=--=-=-=-=-=-=-=--=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=--=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
No comments:
Post a Comment